E J STUTZMAN INC

DOT 1156091 MC 506988 Active

FMCSA records refresh daily. Sourced from public FMCSA datasets - verify with the agency before making business decisions.

Not yet rated
Claim this profile

Heads up - this is a brand new platform. Cargo Credible just launched, and we don't guarantee that every field on this profile is accurate or current. If you spot something that looks wrong, let us know using the button to the right and our team will investigate.

Authority

Common Carrier

Active
Safety
29 inspections

Vehicle OOS: 6.9% (avg 20.7%)

Driver OOS: 16.67% (avg 5.5%)

Fleet
14 units

Drivers: 13

Trailers: 31 (31 owned)

Insurance
BIPD $750,000
Cargo Cancelled
Bond —
Community

No reviews yet

Company Details

Physical Address

726 STATE ROUTE 93 NW, SUGARCREEK, OH, 44681

Phone Number

(330) 852-7888

Mailing Address

P O BOX 484, SUGARCREEK, OH, 44681

Cell Phone

(330) 204-4233

Email Address

[email protected]

Fax Number

(330) 852-8064

Business Organization

CORPORATION

Operational Classification

AUTHORIZED FOR HIRE

Record Changes

Changes detected on this company's public FMCSA record over the last 2 years (legal name, DBA, phone, email, addresses, authority, insurance on file)

View changes across all companies

Sign in to view record changes

Change history on public FMCSA records is available to members.

Log in

Authority & Compliance

Operating Status: Active

Authority Status

Common Carrier

Active
21 yrs, 7 mo

Contract Carrier

—
—

Broker

—
—

Authority History

Date Action Type Status
2013-11-27 DISCONTINUED REVOCATION COMMON ACTIVE
2007-12-03 DISCONTINUED REVOCATION COMMON ACTIVE
2006-11-30 DISCONTINUED REVOCATION COMMON ACTIVE
2005-12-20 DISCONTINUED REVOCATION COMMON ACTIVE
2004-12-28 — MOTOR PROPERTY COMMON CARRIER ACTIVE

Revocation History

No revocation history on record for this carrier.

Insurance & Bond Information

Current insurance coverage and bond requirements by authority type

BIPD Insurance

Bodily Injury & Property Damage

Active

Required for carriers transporting goods. Covers accidents and property damage.

On File: $750,000
Required: $750,000
Cargo Insurance

Cargo Liability Coverage

Cancelled

Covers loss or damage to goods being transported.

Status: Cancelled
Required: Yes
Bond Coverage

Broker/Freight Forwarder Bond

—

Required for brokers/freight forwarders ($75K minimum).

Status: Not Required
Required: No (Carriers exempt)
Insurance Requirements by Authority Type

For Profit Carrier

  • BIPD: $750,000 - $5,000,000 (varies by cargo)
  • Cargo: Varies by commodity
  • Bond: Not required

Broker/Freight Forwarder

  • BIPD: May be required
  • Cargo: Not typically required
  • Bond: $75,000 minimum

Insurance Filing History

Effective Date Type Policy # Coverage Insurer Cancel Date Method Status
2015-12-01 BIPD/Primary CAT 0010768-00 $750,000 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INSURANCE… - - ACTIVE
2014-12-01 BIPD/Primary WF002546 $750,000 NORTHLAND INSURANCE COMPANY 2015-12-01 TERM/REPL CANCELLED
2013-12-01 BIPD/Primary PIA07535601 $750,000 CANAL INSURANCE CO. 2014-12-01 TERM/REPL CANCELLED
2011-10-05 BIPD/Primary CA-X06161 $750,000 ACUITY, A MUTUAL INSURANCE CO… 2013-12-01 CANCEL CANCELLED
2010-12-01 BIPD/Primary CA-X06161 $750,000 ACUITY, A MUTUAL INSURANCE CO… 2011-10-05 TERM/REPL CANCELLED
2010-12-01 CARGO IM-X06161 $750,000 ACUITY, A MUTUAL INSURANCE CO… 2011-04-17 CANCEL CANCELLED
2008-01-02 CARGO TF589854 $750,000 NORTHLAND INSURANCE COMPANY 2010-12-01 TERM/REPL CANCELLED
2007-12-01 BIPD/Primary TF589854 $750,000 NORTHLAND INSURANCE COMPANY 2010-12-01 TERM/REPL CANCELLED
2006-12-01 BIPD/Primary BA611250 $750,000 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INSURANCE C… 2007-12-01 CANCEL CANCELLED
2005-12-21 BIPD/Primary BA611213 $750,000 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INSURANCE C… 2006-12-01 TERM/REPL CANCELLED
2004-12-21 BIPD/Primary 404424 $750,000 CAROLINA CASUALTY INSURANCE C… 2005-12-21 CANCEL CANCELLED
2004-12-20 CARGO CWP 3 929 679 $750,000 WESTFIELD INSURANCE CO. 2008-01-02 TERM/REPL CANCELLED

Safety Performance

Safety rating: Satisfactory

Vehicle OOS Rate

6.9%

National avg: 20.72%

Below average

29 inspections · 2 OOS

Driver OOS Rate

16.67%

National avg: 5.51%

Above average

6 inspections · 1 OOS

Hazmat OOS Rate

-

No hazmat inspections

Total inspections: 29 Last inspection: Jun 4, 2026 Total crashes: 21

FMCSA Inspection Records (29 total)

Detailed inspection history and violations

Jun 4, 2026

0S02803357

Level 2 KY FRHT 3AKJHHDR...

Apr 22, 2026

W125004473

Level 3 MO FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

Mar 13, 2026

8283009954

Level 3 IN FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

Mar 6, 2026

SPA3012093

Level 3 NY FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

Jan 23, 2026

0038000039

1 viol.
Level 3 OH FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

Dec 28, 2025

0006833108

Level 2 NC FRHT 3AKJHHDR...

Dec 5, 2025

PSC1111813

1 viol. 1 OOS
Level 2 WV FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

Nov 4, 2025

CV44832362

1 viol.
Level 1 KY FRHT 3AKJHHDR...

Oct 28, 2025

0396001383

1 viol.
Level 3 GA FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

Oct 9, 2025

9497000035

Level 1 OH FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

Aug 19, 2025

1777000695

Level 2 OH FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

Aug 15, 2025

9512007711

1 viol.
Level 3 IN FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

May 9, 2025

1777000450

Level 3 OH FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

May 5, 2025

I01R260992

Level 1 TN FREIGHTLIN 3AKJHHDR...

Mar 7, 2025

0006735809

Level 3 NC FRHT 3AKJHHDR...
Total Inspections

29

Across all inspection types

Vehicle Inspections

29

FMCSA Accident/Crash Records (21 total)

Detailed accident history and severity information

A portion of FMCSA crash records are reported without a carrier identifier and cannot be attributed to a specific company, so they are not shown on individual profiles. The figures below reflect only the crashes FMCSA links to this carrier.

Jul 6, 2026

OH • OH0268126305

Tow Away

Fatal

0

Injury

0

Tow

Yes

Jun 2, 2022

IN • IN0904050398

Tow Away

Fatal

0

Injury

0

Tow

Yes

Jan 18, 2022

TX • TX68V8HQE15V

Injury

Fatal

0

Injury

2

Tow

No

Sep 6, 2021

OH • OH0216165691

Injury

Fatal

0

Injury

1

Tow

Yes

Jul 22, 2021

MD • MD21A0820719

Injury

Fatal

0

Injury

1

Tow

Yes

Dec 7, 2017

PA • PA713568000X

Injury

Fatal

0

Injury

1

Tow

Yes

Jun 5, 2017

TX • TX4XG8HQE1ZD

Tow Away

Fatal

0

Injury

0

Tow

Yes

Aug 18, 2016

MD • MD16A0257079

Injury

Fatal

0

Injury

1

Tow

Yes

Jul 28, 2016

KY • KY0071817571

Tow Away

Fatal

0

Injury

0

Tow

Yes

Feb 26, 2016

OH • OH0166026850

Injury

Fatal

0

Injury

4

Tow

No

Feb 26, 2016

OH • OH0166026850

Injury

Fatal

0

Injury

4

Tow

No

May 5, 2014

TX • TX41XFHQE1GP

Tow Away

Fatal

0

Injury

0

Tow

Yes

Apr 10, 2014

OH • OH0147025169

Injury

Fatal

0

Injury

1

Tow

Yes

Sep 9, 2013

IL • IL00M2391789

Injury

Fatal

0

Injury

1

Tow

Yes

Feb 19, 2013

OH • OH0136613537

Tow Away

Fatal

0

Injury

0

Tow

Yes
Fatal Crashes

1

Injury Crashes

17

Total Crashes

21

SMS Safety Analysis

BASIC category violations from FMCSA Safety Measurement System

5

Total BASIC Violations

Data from FMCSA SMS

Unsafe Driving

OK
Violations: 1
OOS: 0

Hours-of-Service Compliance

OK
Violations: 1
OOS: 0

Vehicle Maintenance

OK
Violations: 2
OOS: 2

Controlled Substances/Alcohol

OK
Violations: 0
OOS: 0

Driver Fitness

OK
Violations: 1
OOS: 1

Hazardous Materials Compliance

OK
Violations: 0
OOS: 0

BASIC Categories

Unsafe Driving - Speeding, reckless driving
HOS Compliance - Hours of service violations
Vehicle Maintenance - Brakes, lights, tires
Controlled Substances/Alcohol - Drug/alcohol violations
Driver Fitness - Licensing, medical certs
Hazardous Materials Compliance - Hazardous materials

Industry Benchmark

Compare this carrier's metrics against industry expectations

Inspections

Based on reported mileage

29
Expected: 20 - 200 Within Range

Inspections

Based on power units

0
Expected: 80 - 220 Below Range

Power Units

Based on reported mileage

14
Expected: 50 - 250 Small Fleet

Equipment & Drivers

Fleet size, equipment ownership, and driver counts

Tractors

14

4 owned

Trailers

31

31 owned

Drivers

Total Drivers

13

CDL Drivers: 13
Interstate: 13
Intrastate: 0
Driver Inspections

6

Out of Service: 1
OOS Rate: 16.67%
Driver Distribution
Interstate (>100 mi): 13
Interstate (<100 mi): 0
Intrastate (>100 mi): 0
Intrastate (<100 mi): 0

Cargo & Operations

Cargo types hauled and operational classifications

Cargo Carried

General Freight Logs/Lumber Building Materials Machinery

Operation Type

Interstate

Business Organization

CORPORATION

Classification Categories

AUTHORIZED FOR HIRE

Operational Classification

Equipment Overview

14

Power Units

14

Trucks

0

Buses

0

Commercial Vehicles

Ratings & Reviews

Community ratings from brokers and shippers

Reviews are user-submitted opinions, not findings of fact. See our Platform Disclaimer and Review Policy.

No reviews yet - be the first to rate this carrier.

Compare Companies

0 of 4
Select 2-4 companies to compare